CAD to BIM Conversion for Existing Buildings: Challenges, Workflow, and Project BenefitsCAD to BIM Conversion for Existing Buildings: Challenges, Workflow, and Project Benefits

CAD to BIM Conversion for Existing Buildings: Challenges, Workflow, and Project Benefits

UNI Publications
UNI Publications published Blog under AutoCAD Architecture, Autodesk Revit on
CAD drawing to 3D BIM model conversion.
CAD drawing to 3D BIM model conversion.

The existing structures may have more architectural intricacies that cannot be seen in the original drawing of the building. There might be outdated architectural plans, unaccounted for structural alterations, and repeated changes to MEP systems since the time of construction. For all those who plan to renovate the structure, it would pose many problems to solely depend upon the old 2D drawings.

This is where CAD to BIM conversion becomes valuable.

The conversion from traditional CAD drawings to BIM results in a much more systematic digital model of a building. Rather than handling separate lines, signs, and notes, one can work on intelligent 3D objects with various properties and information.

But the conversion from CAD drawings of the existing building to BIM is not simply about opening a DWG file in Revit and making a 3D model out of it. It involves drawing analysis, architecture interpretation, dimension checking, modeling, and quality assurance.

In this article, we will consider the main difficulties of CAD to BIM conversion of the existing buildings, the procedure used by specialists, and the advantages such a project may have.

Why Existing Buildings Need CAD to BIM Conversion

Many commercial, institutional, health care, industrial, and residential buildings were first drafted using traditional CAD drafting techniques. Though these drawings provide valuable information, they do not have the intelligence and coordination necessary for modern construction and facility management projects.

For instance, while an architectural drawing will have the walls, their positioning, boundaries of rooms, and even doors, it will not necessarily have the information that will help understand the wall construction, material types, and interaction with structures and MEP.

The same case applies to a mechanical drawing where the ductwork and equipment positioning are shown without having a coordinated system for interaction with the structure of the building.

This is where CAD to BIM conversion comes in.

Some of the advantages of a BIM model developed from such an assessment include:

  • A three-dimensional comprehension of the building layout.
  • Relationships between architectural, structural, and mechanical systems.
  • Integration for renovations and retrofits.
  • Checking of spatial considerations before construction.
  • Production of new plans, sections, elevations, and schedules.
  • Facilitation of building operations and management.

BIM's effectiveness in renovation is highly reliant on how accurate the model is compared to the real-life building. That is why the analysis of existing CAD data should be considered as the first step.

Major Challenges in CAD to BIM Conversion for Existing Buildings

The translation of CAD drawings to BIM models of existing buildings is not without its difficulties. The extent of the difficulty will depend on the age of the building, the quality of the drawings, the documents available, the scope of the project, and the LOD needed.

1. Incomplete or Outdated CAD Drawings

Incomplete and outdated source drawings are the most frequent problems that we face.There is a high probability that the old building will have undergone many renovations and changes in its structure. But at the same time, the DWG file may not consider all of them.

For example, there might be a partition wall placed in the original place on the architectural drawing, while in actuality, it has been extended through renovations. Also, there may be some ducts, cables, and other equipment not included in the mechanical, electrical, and plumbing drawings.

This situation leads to the creation of inaccurate BIM models.

How to address it: Before the model-making stage, the whole project team should do a thorough examination of the architectural, structural, and mechanical, electrical, and plumbing drawing set. All inconsistencies should be identified, and important dimensions should be verified through surveys or laser scans if required.

2. Inconsistent Drawing Standards and Layer Organization

CAD models created over a period of time can be done according to varying drafting standards.

Whereas in one drawing the layers may have been properly named with respect to walls, doors, windows, and dimensions, another drawing could have badly-named layers, overlapping linework, or unnecessary elements grouped.

Typical problems faced are:

  • Non-standard layer names.
  • Overlapping and duplicated linework.
  • Incorrect lineweights and drawing scale.
  • Unnecessary blocks and Xrefs.
  • Missing dimensions and annotations.
  • Different coordinate systems between drawings.

It becomes very difficult to understand the drawing data and pick out the right geometry for BIM modeling. CAD Cleaning is important before conversion. This includes cleaning up unwanted elements, ensuring drawing units, layer management, fixing external references, and many more.

3. Limited Information About Existing Building Conditions

The CAD drawing shows the design data, which may not necessarily depict the present condition of the building.

This is especially significant for old buildings, whereby unrecorded modifications might have been made over the years.

For example, the dimensions of a column may be different from those shown in the drawing. The ceiling height may be affected by the installation of more facilities, and the openings may have been modified to accommodate equipment.

Without these, even though the BIM may have captured the drawings accurately, it may be depicting the building in the wrong way.

In the case where uncertainties are present regarding the existing conditions, verification becomes necessary. Laser scanning and point cloud data may provide a better source from which to develop the as-built model. In situations where laser scanning is not possible, certain measurements and photos may come in handy.

4. Modeling Complex Architectural and Structural Elements

The existing buildings may have architectural or structural elements that cannot be easily created through the standard BIM families.

This may include the irregular shape of walls, curved stairs, sloping ceilings, ornamental facades, nonstandard openings, and structural junctions.

Historic buildings may pose more challenges since their construction details may not conform to current architectural designs.

The modeler will then need to determine which modeling approach should be used.

3D BIM Modeling techniques need to be determined depending on the LOD that is needed and how the model will be used. Standard objects need to use suitable parametric families when possible, while complex and irregular objects may need special parametric families.

5. Architectural, Structural, and MEP Coordination

Current renovation works of buildings include several specialties working with different CAD drawings.

When these drawings are converted individually, there may be conflicts among the architectural, structural, and MEP drawings.

For instance, there could be a clash between an HVAC duct and the existing beam or a plumbing run interfering with structural drawings. There could also be electrical cable trays that require extra room in the existing ceiling, which may not be available.

How to address it: Each field must adopt the common modeling standards, coordinate systems, and file exchanges. Once all models have been designed, it is important to review them in a coordinated manner through the use of coordination software such as Autodesk Navisworks or Revit.

BIM coordination: a clash detected between HVAC ductwork and a structural beam.
BIM coordination: a clash detected between HVAC ductwork and a structural beam.

6. Managing Model Detail and File Performance

Not all existing buildings require an overly detailed BIM model.

Unnecessary geometries, too many families, or any other kind of data not necessary for accomplishing the project goals will make the model larger and decrease its efficiency.

It is especially true of large commercial buildings, industrial plants, hospitals, or multi-building campuses.

The LOD requirement, scope of modeling, and information requirements need to be established before initiating the process. The process of modeling needs to consider only those components that will aid the design, construction, coordination, or operational processes.

CAD to BIM Conversion Workflow for Existing Buildings

The use of a conversion workflow will ensure that accuracy and coordination in the models is maintained.

Although the processes will vary depending on the project, the procedure stated below works well.

The conversion process requires more than transferring 2D drawing information into a 3D environment. It involves reviewing source drawings, establishing project standards, developing discipline-specific models, and checking coordination between building systems. For a closer look at the technical stages involved, read this CAD to Revit conversion workflow guide, which explains how 2D drawings are developed into coordinated BIM models.

The CAD to BIM conversion workflow for existing buildings.
The CAD to BIM conversion workflow for existing buildings.

Step 1: Review and Assess Existing CAD Drawings

The first stage would entail the collection and analysis of all project documentation available.

The following may be considered such documents:

  • Building construction plans.
  • Frames and foundations plan.
  • Plumbing and mechanical system plans.
  • Electrical and fire safety plans.
  • Sections and details.
  • Renovation plans.

Finding the absence of data, inconsistencies in the drawings, and information that should be verified is essential now.

The purpose of this stage is the analysis of available data in order to determine whether it is sufficient for the BIM modeling or additional data should be collected from the construction site.

Step 2: Clean and Prepare CAD Files

Once the review of the drawings is done, then comes the stage of preparing the drawings for the modeling process.

This step primarily includes cleaning up any excess linework, modifying the drawing units, fixing the external references, layering, and checking the coordinates.

It is essential to have matching reference points on architectural, structural, and MEP drawings.

This would prevent any unnecessary complications in the modeling process.

Step 3: Verify Existing Building Conditions

When there is a possibility that the original drawings will not reflect the actual condition of the building, physical proof becomes necessary.

The options, depending on the needs of the project, include:

  • Site measuring.
  • Photographic record.
  • Terrestrial laser scanning.
  • Mobile scanning/photogrammetry.
  • Point cloud registration.

Laser scanning is particularly useful for documenting geometries and discovering any discrepancies between documentation and reality.

This point cloud may be used for creating BIM models. Some software programs exist that allow this. One of them is Autodesk ReCap, which is able to register and clean point clouds for future use in Revit and other similar programs.

Step 4: Establish the BIM Project Environment

The creation of a BIM environment must take place before modeling begins and according to the requirements of the project.

These include the following:

  • Project units and coordinate system.
  • Levels and grids.
  • Project base point and common coordinates.
  • View templates and work sets.
  • Standard naming conventions.
  • BIM execution plan.
  • Level of detail required.

Multidisciplinary projects benefit from setting these standards at the beginning, as different parties can create their models and coordinate them without extra effort.

Step 5: Develop the Architectural BIM Model

Typically, the architectural model is developed through the use of the created CAD drawings and verified condition data.

Some typical architectural components are:

  • Walls inside and outside the building.
  • Doors and windows.
  • Floor slabs and floor finishes.
  • Roofs and ceilings.
  • Stairs and railings.
  • Room layouts and spaces.
  • Facade components and architectural components.

This type of component is created using suitable Revit tools and families.

When needed, families can be created to model some non-typical architectural components.

The main idea is to create an architectural model rather than recreate the appearance of the original CAD drawing.

Step 6: Develop Structural and MEP Models

Based on the architectural model, both structural and MEP models can be created through their source drawings and verified site information.

The examples of structural BIM modeling include:

  • Foundation and footings.
  • Columns and beams.
  • Structures and structural walls.
  • Slabs and floors.
  • Bracing and framing members.

The examples of MEP BIM modeling include:

  • Ducts and HVAC.
  • Pipes and plumbing.
  • Conduits and cable tray.
  • Electrical systems and lighting fixtures.
  • Fire protection systems.

The amount of information to be collected on each component should be based on the project requirements. It is important to distinguish between verified information, assumptions, and proposed changes in the case of an existing building renovation project.

Step 7: Coordinate Models and Perform Quality Checks

Once all the models in each field have been constructed, the next phase will involve carrying out an evaluation to check consistency and coordination.

Typical quality control involves:

  • Model consistency and coordinate systems.
  • Geometrical accuracy when compared to the source information.
  • Omissions and repetitions.
  • Wrong levels and dimensions.
  • Family and parameter consistency.
  • Architectural and structural clashes.
  • MEP clash and spatial coordination.
  • Model and file performance.

The Navisworks software will help to identify discipline conflicts, while Revit will be used for verifying the elements of the model.

If laser scan data exists, the developed model can be verified against the point cloud.

Step 8: Deliver the BIM Model and Supporting Documentation

Step 5 entails preparing the BIM deliverables based on the defined project scope.

Some of the deliverables to be delivered could be:

  • Native Revit model (RVT).
  • CAD drawings (DWG).
  • IFC export.
  • Integrated multi-disciplinary model.
  • Updated floor plan and elevation views.
  • Sections and construction details.
  • Schedules and quantities.
  • BIM documentation and turnover packages.

The deliverable must identify all assumptions made, unidentified conditions, and limitations.

This is particularly crucial when the BIM model will be used for renovation design, construction coordination, or facilities management.

Project Benefits of CAD to BIM Conversion for Existing Buildings

Provided that it is done using proper source data and controls, CAD-to-BIM conversion offers practical advantages throughout the building’s lifecycle. Provided that it is done using proper source data and controls, CAD-to-BIM conversion offers practical advantages throughout the building’s lifecycle.

1. Better Understanding of Existing Building Conditions

A synchronized 3D model using BIM gives more clarity about the geometry and spatial relationship of a building than disconnected 2D drawings.

It allows architects to look at room layout, wall arrangement, and openings while giving engineers an opportunity to analyze structural and MEP relationships.

This helps in better understanding the design of the project.

2. Improved Renovation and Retrofit Planning

In most cases, renovation works entail modifications to spaces, structures, and utilities already in place.

The BIM model acts as a controlled platform where such modifications can be analyzed before starting construction.

For instance, the engineer can determine whether new ducting will fit in the ceiling cavity or the modification will impact any structural element.

3. Reduced Design Errors and Rework

Using separate CAD drawings may hinder the detection of conflicts between various disciplines.

The federated BIM solution enables the combined review of data pertaining to architecture, structure, and mechanical-electrical-plumbing engineering.

It assists project teams in early conflict detection and resolution before implementation.

But BIM cannot detect design problems automatically. It is dependent on the precision of the data used, modeling standards, and processes of coordination.

An integrated 3D BIM model of an existing commercial building.
An integrated 3D BIM model of an existing commercial building.

4. More Efficient Project Documentation

As soon as the BIM model is developed, the team can create plans, sections, elevations, and schedules based on information contained in the model.

If the model is correctly set up, the modifications that will be performed in the model will also appear in the corresponding views.

This minimizes the effort that goes into updating various disconnected drawings.

5. Better Quantity Estimation and Cost Planning

The BIM models may have data regarding element dimensions, materials, and quantities.

The said information may be used for quantity takeoff estimation, renovation, and cost planning.

For instance, a contractor can utilize model information in estimating floor areas, number of walls, doors, or even number of structural elements.

The accuracy of such estimates will depend on model information and the level of detail contained in the deliverables.

6. Long-Term Facility Management Support

The advantages of CAD-to-BIM conversion do not have to be realized only after the completion of renovation activities.

A properly generated as-built BIM model can serve as a valuable digital aid for facility managers.

The information contained within the model can be used by building managers to know the location of the equipment, define service areas, examine room layouts, and assist in maintenance planning.

In large buildings, the same information can be utilized for future digital twin projects if the model is properly maintained.

Factors to Consider Before Starting a CAD to BIM Conversion Project

Prior to hiring any BIM service provider or initiating a BIM conversion process internally, there are a few things that need to be established.

Goals: Understand how the model is going to be used – will it be for renovation design, clash detection, construction documentation, quantity take-off, or facility management?

Current condition of DWG drawings: Understand the current condition of DWG drawings that exist and what information is missing.

Verification of current condition: Understand whether surveys, laser scanning or point cloud processing is required.

Criteria for LOD: Establish the level of LOD and information that would be needed.

Software & Deliverables: Understand the software and deliverable types.

BIM criteria: Naming convention, coordinate system, family criteria, quality criteria.

These criteria help ensure that the scope issues do not come up in the future.

Final Words

Conversion of CAD data to BIM for an existing building is a critical component in advancing the process of planning and executing building renovation, retrofits, and modernization efforts.

But efficient conversion goes beyond simply moving CAD geometry to a 3D space. It requires analyzing existing drawings, assessing physical condition, setting up modeling standards, creating models specific to each discipline, and conducting quality assessment.

When carried out in a proper manner, the process of BIM conversion will give architects, engineers, builders, and the owner of the building a greater level of coordination with regard to existing buildings.

Regardless of whether the aim is modernizing an office building, renovating a hospital, upgrading an industrial plant, or making building management more efficient at a commercial complex, an accurate BIM model can help achieve better coordination and decision-making.

In essence, the process of converting CAD to BIM is valuable because of the transformation of existing building information into a digital model.

Share your ideas with the world

Share your ideas with the world

Write about your design process, research, or opinions. Your voice matters in the architecture community.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Similar Reads

You might also enjoy these articles

publishedBlog7 hours ago
BLT Arquitectos Wraps a Shared Innovation Hub at Córdoba's Catholic University in a Glowing Polycarbonate Shed
publishedBlog7 hours ago
Charlene Koetz Arquitetura Lifts a Glass House on Piers Above a Mossy Forest Slope in Gramado
publishedBlog7 hours ago
Paul Bernier Architecte Turns a Curved-Eaved 1970s Cottage in Magog into a Year-Round Family Home
publishedBlog7 hours ago
Peris and Toral.arquitectes Wrap 54 Social Rental Homes in Besòs Around a Brick-Screened Atrium

Explore AutoCAD Architecture Competitions

Discover active competitions in this discipline

UNI Publications