UN/DEFINED: Thu Thiem Market: Organised Informality Arranged Around a Communal PlazaUN/DEFINED: Thu Thiem Market: Organised Informality Arranged Around a Communal Plaza

UN/DEFINED: Thu Thiem Market: Organised Informality Arranged Around a Communal Plaza

Most market redevelopments start by erasing the very thing that made the old market worth visiting: the improvised stall, the crooked lane, the table pulled out wherever there is shade. The usual result is a clean grid with nobody in it. This proposal starts from the opposite instinct. It treats informality as a design asset that deserves structure, not removal.

UN/DEFINED: Thu Thiem Market is a market proposal for Vietnam by Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag and Anna Thum. It was Shortlisted at Street City Vietnam. The team builds the scheme on what they call organised informality, a concept that depends on the participation and collaboration of the local community and fishermen, and pairs it with participatory design, adaptable buildings, sustainable design, space optimisation, improved social life and human scale.

A Radial Plaza Pulls Scattered Stalls Into Orbit

The site plan reads like a village caught mid-gathering. Small gabled market houses are set at shifting angles around a circular plaza, none of them quite aligned with its neighbour, yet all of them turned loosely toward the centre. Faint concentric rings in the paving hint at the order underneath the apparent looseness. A long tiled-roof hall runs along one edge of the site, a single calm volume that steadies the field of smaller buildings beside it.

This is where the title earns its slash. The plan is defined enough to guarantee a heart, a shaded edge and a clear back line, but undefined enough that the gaps between stalls become alleys, pockets and short cuts. Trees occupy several of those gaps, so the leftover space is never purely leftover. From above, the translucent ridges on the stall roofs make each unit legible as a repeatable module, which is exactly what a participatory, adaptable market needs.

Site plan view from above showing gabled market houses arranged radially around a central plaza with tables, trees and a long hall at right. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Site plan view from above showing gabled market houses arranged radially around a central plaza with tables, trees and a long hall at right. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Aerial view of small gabled brick market houses ringing a circular plaza with round tables, beside a long tiled-roof hall. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Aerial view of small gabled brick market houses ringing a circular plaza with round tables, beside a long tiled-roof hall. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum

Narrow Brick Lanes Keep Trade at Arm's Length

At street level the angled placement pays off. Lanes narrow and widen as you walk, and the stalls press close enough that goods sit within reach of passers-by. Brick walls give the units weight and a sense of permanence, while timber balconies, folding counters and fabric canopies strung across the lane do the softer work of shading and adjusting. Red paper lanterns hang overhead, tying separate stalls into a single street.

The human-scale ambition named in the description is visible here more than anywhere. Nothing in these lanes is taller than it needs to be, and upper floors step out as balconies rather than stacking up as blank façades. A fruit cart and a vendor in a conical hat share the cobbles with a backpacker, and the architecture accommodates both without sorting them into separate zones.

Rendered market lane lined with brick stalls, fabric canopies and red paper lanterns, with a tree ahead and shoppers in conical hats. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Rendered market lane lined with brick stalls, fabric canopies and red paper lanterns, with a tree ahead and shoppers in conical hats. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Narrow brick-walled lane with timber balconies, canopies and a fruit cart, under a blue sky with scattered clouds and a backpacker walking. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Narrow brick-walled lane with timber balconies, canopies and a fruit cart, under a blue sky with scattered clouds and a backpacker walking. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum

A Tree and a Bench Do the Work of a Town Square

One of the most persuasive moments in the set is also one of the smallest. A tree grows straight through a timber bench planter in the middle of a market street, and an elder sits on its edge while shoppers move around him. The bench turns an obstacle into a resting point; the tree turns a corridor into a place. It is the kind of detail that informal markets produce by accident and that formal ones rarely plan for, and here it is planned on purpose.

Cobbled market street with a tree growing through a timber bench planter, vendors, a seated elder and a passing hat-wearing walker. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Cobbled market street with a tree growing through a timber bench planter, vendors, a seated elder and a passing hat-wearing walker. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum

Long Tables Turn the Market Into a Dining Room

The central plaza is less a void than a shared room. Communal wooden tables and benches fill the cobbles, pigeons pick at the ground, and diners sit together under strings of lanterns. In afternoon light it reads as a lunch spot for traders; at dusk the same tables fill with crowds and the plaza becomes an evening destination. The stalls around the ring act as the walls of this room, their counters facing the people eating.

This is where improved social life, one of the project's stated goals, becomes spatial rather than rhetorical. By placing the largest open space at the centre of the trading activity, the scheme makes lingering the default. Buying, cooking, eating and talking happen in one continuous field, which is how the best street markets already work.

Plaza with communal wooden tables and benches, pigeons on cobbles, red lanterns overhead and diners seated in afternoon light. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Plaza with communal wooden tables and benches, pigeons on cobbles, red lanterns overhead and diners seated in afternoon light. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Rendering of a cobbled market street lined with brick buildings, red paper lanterns and crowds at outdoor tables at dusk. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum
Rendering of a cobbled market street lined with brick buildings, red paper lanterns and crowds at outdoor tables at dusk. Image: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum

Why This Project Matters

Markets in fast-changing cities are often the first casualties of modernisation, replaced by halls that are tidy, efficient and lifeless. UN/DEFINED argues that the qualities people value in informal trade, the tight lanes, the improvised seating, the shade found between buildings, can be designed for rather than designed out. Its loose radial plan shows how a small set of rules can hold together a place that still feels self-made.

Just as important is who the scheme is for. By resting its concept on the participation of the local community and fishermen, the proposal frames architecture as a framework that people complete, not a finished object handed down to them. That stance, combined with modest materials and a firm commitment to human scale, makes it a useful reference for anyone thinking about how public markets can evolve without losing their street life.


View the Full Project

Project team

Designers: Nurin Abdullah, Hossam ElYamani, Ahd Farrag, Anna Thum

Competition and award

Shortlisted, Street City Vietnam

Location

Vietnam

Enter a Design Competition on uni.xyz

uni.xyz runs architecture and design competitions year-round that reward proposals with spatial conviction and real site intelligence.

UNI logo
UNI Editorial

UNI Editorial

Where architecture meets innovation, through curated news, insights, and reviews from around the globe.

Share your ideas with the world

Share your ideas with the world

Write about your design process, research, or opinions. Your voice matters in the architecture community.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Similar Reads

You might also enjoy these articles

publishedResults1 month ago
Healing Façade: A Modular Chapel System That Restores Ethiopia's Sacred Forests
publishedResults1 month ago
Kaffeebühnen: Where Coffee Shop Architecture Becomes a Civic Stage in Vienna
publishedResults1 month ago
Eco Chapel: A Modular Forest Pavilion That Grows Like the Landscape It Protects
publishedResults6 months ago
Urban Forest: A Vertical Ecosystem for 5,000 Workers in Singapore's Changi Business Park

Explore Sustainable Design Competitions

Discover active competitions in this discipline