Rethinking Walls: Turning a Dividing Wall in Peru into the Terraced Backbone of a Shared HillsideRethinking Walls: Turning a Dividing Wall in Peru into the Terraced Backbone of a Shared Hillside

Rethinking Walls: Turning a Dividing Wall in Peru into the Terraced Backbone of a Shared Hillside

Most proposals that confront a dividing wall reach for the bulldozer. Demolition is the obvious gesture, the photogenic one, and often the least honest. A wall that has defined a place, even for the worst reasons, leaves a mark on the people on both sides. Erasing it does not erase that mark. The harder question is what the wall could become if it stayed and changed its job.

Rethinking Walls, by Marcelo Santos, takes that harder route on a steep site in Peru. The project received Editor's Choice at Divide 13. Its premise is stated plainly: a wall does not need to be a barrier if it is used the proper way, and an element that gave an area its character for bad reasons can be looked at with a new set of eyes.

One Wall Multiplied into Many Terrace Edges

The key move is multiplication. Instead of a single line cutting the hillside, the scheme breaks the wall into a series of low retaining edges, each one holding a platform. The aerial graphic slices the drawing into horizontal bands as though the wall itself had been pulled apart and reassembled as stepped ground. Pale pink walls, light plazas and clusters of palms read as one continuous landscape rather than two sides of a border.

This changes what a wall does spatially. A barrier works vertically, blocking movement and sight. A terrace wall works horizontally: it makes flat ground on a slope, gives people a ledge to sit on and frames a view down the hill. The same material that once separated now becomes, in the project's own words, the backbone of a new community.

RETHINKING WALLS - A wall doesn't need to be a barrier; it can be deconstructed, it can be the backbone of a new community. Image: Marcelo Santos
RETHINKING WALLS - A wall doesn't need to be a barrier; it can be deconstructed, it can be the backbone of a new community. Image: Marcelo Santos

A Portal and a Mural Where the Wall Is Crossed

The entrance portal is where the concept becomes tangible. A thick pale frame opens onto the hillside, and beside it the wall surface carries a large painted face mural. An elderly couple, a dog walker and a parent with a child share the plaza in the rendering. The wall stays visible and even celebrated, yet it is now a surface for art and a doorway rather than a blank face. It is a convincing image of a wall that has been given a new symbolic charge.

Whether those side gateways actually guarantee openness is another matter, and Cynthia Seinfeld Lemlig, who judged the competition, pressed hard on the point. She welcomed the idea of re-meaning the wall but warned that lateral entrances can be closed by either population, and questioned how the accesses relate to Casuarinas on one side and a school on the other. Her comments also praise the ramp work and call for a stronger bridge, which makes them a useful map of the whole scheme.

- The idea of re meaning the wall by giving it another symbolic connotation seems interesting to me; however, it loses strength when it is not treated from the edge, that currently generates separation. On the other hand, in contrast, the idea of accessing from these side gateways is a double-edged sword. These take the risk of being closed by any of the populations involved, preventing the desired integration. That is, the entrance would no longer be freely accessible, but would be conditioned by unilateral decisions, such as, for example, the school that is located on one side of the field.
- In addition, one of the proposed lateral entrances responds to accesses for the population of Casuarinas, and on the other side, it is in close relationship with the school; therefore, there is an inaccuracy in the approach.
- An interesting work is read of ramps and widens that adjust to the topography and the slope in a natural way. In addition, there is a correlation with the way in which the populations have settled on the hills, with an organic and versatile layout in their plots, with compactness in their spaces and intersecting streets as an unforeseen route. It would have been interesting if these ramps had permeable lateral edges to strengthen the layout and allow access with greater freedom in order to generate greater dynamism in its use.
- It would be interesting to reinforce the design of the extensions, assuming their characterization according to uses, the need for shade, etc. It is necessary to reinforce the activities along the route.
- The bridge lacks strength as a referential milestone in the proposal. In addition, it would have been interesting for it to be integrated into the proposal from both sides, with the ramps and the routes.Cynthia Seinfeld Lemlig, Co-Founder / Main Architect, Seinfeld arquitectos/ Tandem Arquitectura, Lima, Peru
Rendered view of the entrance portal beside a large painted face mural, with an elderly couple and a dog walker crossing the pale plaza. Image: Marcelo Santos
Rendered view of the entrance portal beside a large painted face mural, with an elderly couple and a dog walker crossing the pale plaza. Image: Marcelo Santos

Ramps That Fold into Market, Amphitheatre and Court

The strongest part of the proposal is its circulation. Ramps climb between platforms at gentle angles, and where they turn, the folds widen into places. One rendering shows terraced amphitheatre steps with people lounging on them, a market area further along and a basketball court on an open hillside platform, all above a hazy city. Another sits inside a walled terrace where striped market stalls stand between palm trunks, a cat perched on the low wall and the access ramps rising behind. The walls here are seat height or waist height: they shelter and organise without enclosing.

Rodolfo Jaime Cortegana Morgan, who also judged the competition, read this layout as a coherent way of settling into desert terrain, with ramps that generate program at their points of folding. He connected the approach to an architecture that understands the desert of ancient Peru, and valued the mix of uses as a landscape to be lived in rather than looked at.

Esta propuesta reconoce en el trazo una coherencia de implantación en el territorio desértico resolviendo habitar la ladera desde unas rampas que generarn un programa en sus momentos de pliegue.
Esto es el reconocimiento de una arquitectura que entiende el desierto en el antiguo Perú, nos parece interesante que el trazo genera una posibilidad múltiple de tiempos, estancias, ocio y se convierte en un espacio no necesariamente productivo en los términos mas clásico sino en un espacio de bienestar.
La heterogeneidad del programa muestra la posibilidad de ser un proyecto más sustentable en el tiempo, el proyecto al final construye un paisaje habitado y no de contemplación.Rodolfo Jaime Cortegana Morgan, Lead architect, Llosa Cortegana Arquitectos, Lima, Peru
Rendered view of terraced amphitheatre steps, market area and basketball court on a hillside platform, with people lounging above a hazy city. Image: Marcelo Santos
Rendered view of terraced amphitheatre steps, market area and basketball court on a hillside platform, with people lounging above a hazy city. Image: Marcelo Santos
Rendered view of striped market stalls between palm trunks inside a pale walled terrace, with a cat on the wall and ramps behind. Image: Marcelo Santos
Rendered view of striped market stalls between palm trunks inside a pale walled terrace, with a cat on the wall and ramps behind. Image: Marcelo Santos

A Cantilevered Viewpoint at the Top of the Climb

At the upper edge, a deck projects out from the stepped platforms. The view toward it crosses a sequence of levels: market stalls under palms, people sitting on terrace edges, and a multifunctional platform labelled for sports, dance, music and theatre. The viewpoint caps the route and turns the reward of climbing into a shared horizon over the city.

This is also where the project feels least resolved. As Seinfeld Lemlig noted, the bridge does not yet carry the weight of a landmark, and tying it into the ramps from both sides would make it part of the route rather than an object at its end. The diagnosis is fair, and it points to a design that could push its best idea, the folding ramp, even further.

Rendered view across stepped platforms toward a cantilevered viewpoint deck, with palms and a leafy tree against a wide city skyline. Image: Marcelo Santos
Rendered view across stepped platforms toward a cantilevered viewpoint deck, with palms and a leafy tree against a wide city skyline. Image: Marcelo Santos

Why This Project Matters

Rethinking Walls argues that the memory of division can be kept and redirected rather than erased. By breaking one dividing line into many terrace edges, it converts a structure of exclusion into one of support: walls that hold ground, offer seats, frame stalls and carry murals. The idea is simple enough to communicate in a single diagram and spatial enough to generate a whole hillside of uses.

The jury's critique sharpens rather than undermines that value. Access that depends on a gate can be revoked, and edges that are too solid can rebuild the separation they meant to undo. The lesson for anyone working on divided territory is clear: integration is decided at the threshold and along the route. Where this scheme lets its ramps fold freely into program, it shows how a wall can become common ground.


View the Full Project

Project team

Designer: Marcelo Santos

Competition and award

Editor's Choice, Divide 13

Jury

Cynthia Seinfeld Lemlig, Co-Founder / Main Architect, Seinfeld arquitectos/ Tandem Arquitectura, Lima, PeruRodolfo Jaime Cortegana Morgan, Lead architect, Llosa Cortegana Arquitectos, Lima, Peru

Location

Peru

Enter a Design Competition on uni.xyz

uni.xyz runs architecture and design competitions year-round that reward proposals with spatial conviction and real site intelligence.

UNI logo
UNI Editorial

UNI Editorial

Where architecture meets innovation, through curated news, insights, and reviews from around the globe.

Share your ideas with the world

Share your ideas with the world

Write about your design process, research, or opinions. Your voice matters in the architecture community.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Similar Reads

You might also enjoy these articles

publishedResults1 month ago
Healing Façade: A Modular Chapel System That Restores Ethiopia's Sacred Forests
publishedResults1 month ago
Kaffeebühnen: Where Coffee Shop Architecture Becomes a Civic Stage in Vienna
publishedResults1 month ago
Eco Chapel: A Modular Forest Pavilion That Grows Like the Landscape It Protects
publishedResults6 months ago
Urban Forest: A Vertical Ecosystem for 5,000 Workers in Singapore's Changi Business Park

Explore Architecture Competitions

Discover active competitions in this discipline